Providing
Support for Debatable Statements (or Conclusions)
You now know that debatable statements are not statements of fact
but are statements or conclusions* with which other people may or may
not agree. When you are writing an argumentative essay your aim is
to make your readers agree with your debatable statements or conclusions.
You need to convince your readers of the value or truth of your conclusions.
But by themselves, they are not convincing - they need support.
In this section, you will learn how to provide
supporting statements for your conclusions. (We will use the term "conclusion" from
now on for any debatable statement or assertion in your argumentative
essay). You will also learn how to use connectives to link these statements
to each other and to the conclusion.
*The word "conclusion" is the same as "thesis" in
this context.
Example
1
Conclusion:
Marijuana should be legalized
Supporting statement 1:
It is less harmful to people's health than alcohol.
Supporting statement 2:
A very large percentage of the population uses it.
Both supporting statements provide
information that helps prove or support the conclusion. We can use
connectives to link these statements together:
Example 2
Conclusion:
Marijuana should be legalized
Supporting statement 1:
Firstly, it is less harmful
to people's health than alcohol.
Supporting statement 2:
In addition, a very large
percentage of the population uses it.
Firstly tells the reader
that this is the first supporting statement. (There are no other
formal connectives that can be used in this place. It is, however,
acceptable to have no connective here)
In addition tells the reader
that this is an extra supporting statement. Other connectives
that you could use here are Furthermore,
Moreover and Secondly.
Task 1
The following conclusions (C) have one supporting statement
(SS1). Rewrite them adding a second supporting statement
(SS2). Also use connectives for the first and second supporting
statements
Immigration
(C)
A strong immigration program is necessary in Australia
(SS1)
The population is too small for sustained economic growth
(SS2)
Smoking
(C)
Smoking should be banned in restaurants and pubs.
(SS1)
It will help people to give up this unhealthy habit.
(SS2)
Freeways
(C)
The government should build more freeways instead of public
transport.
(SS1)
It keeps traffic off residential streets.
(SS2)
Public Transport
(C)
The government should build more public transport instead of
freeways.
(SS1)
It provides cheap transport to people who can't afford cars.
(SS2)
After you have completed this task, check here
for suggested or possible answers.